How the militia movement is americas domestic viet cong asymmetrical warfare and 4gw. Fourth generation warfare is a conflict between a state actor and a nonstate 4gw actor. Over the last decade, theres been a lot of discussion of 4th generation warfare. The term fourth generation warfare 4gw was first used in an article of the marine corps gazette from 1989. They are more persistent than other nerve agents and are at least as toxic as vx. The military doctrine was first defined in 1989 by a team of american analysts, including william. In this example, hammes uses the phrase netsandjets war to describe the second alternative form of fifth generation warfare he proposes. In 4gw, an army structured for earlier generations of warfare is. Second generation warfare involved rifles and gunpowder. National war college, the naval and army war colleges, and the british joint command and staff college. He previously had established the ideas of first, second and third generation warfare in the 1980s. How militia groups are americas domestic viet cong youre free to republish or share any of our articles either in part or in full, which are licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.
The oxford history of modern war central intelligence agency. The fifth generation warfare notion wraps up networkcentric warfare, combat cloud, multidomain battle, and fusion warfare concepts. Fourth generation warfare 4gw is described by the authors as follows. Sep 29, 2010 fifth generation warfare a growing concept a new and very interesting concept is growing among a community of dedicated national security professionals. The man who came up with the concept of 4gw, william s. This defines 5gw, noncontact warfare in the present context. According to their views, fourth generation warfare can be seen as a twilight zone between war and peace, between civilian and military, between tactics and strategy. Englishlanguage summary of a phd dissertation on asymmetric or fourth generation warfare. This project will discuss the theory of fourth generation warfare and highlight its distinct characteristics. Lind, to describe warfares return to a decentralized form.
Fourth generation conflicts lessons and characteristics. A practical manifestation of 5th generation warfare. Fifth generation warfare will result from the continued shift of political and social loyalties to causes rather than nations. The term was first used in 1989 by a team of united states analysts, including william s. These include diplomats, soldiers, law enforcement officers, intelligence operatives, cyber warriors and development specialists. Fourth generation warfare is compared with jelly because of its various varieties in shapes, which are not constant, can be molded into any structure and form, also which is not sticky like a glue on any certain things. Although war is evolving, in response to changes in the worlds social, political, and economic condition as well as to the introduction of new technologies, it is important to keep in mind that it is still war, that is, an attempt to coerce another group of people into doing. Youth revolt and generation formation in germany 17701968 1995.
The simplest definition includes any war in which one of the major participants is not a state but rather a violent ideological network. Characteristics such as decentralization and initiative carry over from the third to the fourth generation, but in other respects the. Hammes, used to describe the decentralized nature of modern warfare. Conflict in the 21st century potomac institute for policy. If we combine the above general characteristics of fourth generation warfare with new technology, we see one possible outline of the new generation. Fourthgeneration warfare is conflict characterized by a blurring of the lines between war and politics, soldier and civilian. Fourth generation warfare 4gw is conflict characterized by a blurring of the lines between war and politics, combatants and civilians the term was first used in 1989 by a team of united states analysts, including paleoconservative william s. The common characteristic of the first three generations of warfare. Same is the case with the nature and characteristics of fourth generation warfare. The oxford history of modern war charles townshend editor oxford university press. In the light of facts discussed above, it is evident that ptm is a tool of hybrid warfare used by antipakistan forces to crush pakistans strength and to challenge her existence. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading 4th generation warfare handbook. The light infantryman is characterized by his mental resourcefulness and physical toughness. I beheld, and lo, there was no man, and all the birds of the heavens were fled.
The only hope they had of generating enough fire to inflict high casualties was by the use of dense and well disciplined shooting structures. This changes when we move on to fourth generation warfare, where one of the opponents is. Pdf fourth generation warfare and the clash of civilizations. While the first three generations of warfare were clearly delineated, the fourth generation warfare 4gw obscures more than it explains. Fourth generation warfare jihad and the jihadist networks. It continues to be regarded as the nations premier center of its kind. Fourthgeneration war and other myths semantic scholar. First generation warfare uses the muscular power of the fighting men to accomplish the aims of warfare and battle. Military response to fourth generation warfare in afghanistan by greg wilcox and gary i. Wilson marine corps gazette december 1994, pages 3437 events of the past 5 years have not greatly altered the views of the fourth generationists. It identifies the roots of asymmetric warfare and the reasons for its dominance today. I call this framework the four generations of modern war. Careful readers may have noted that first, second, and third generation warfare represented increasingly sophisticated ways for state armies to fight other state armies.
In 1989, the year of the fall of the wall, of the fall of the communist dictatorship in eastern europe, the authors of an article entitled face of war into the fourth generation offered a glimpse of the future rooted in the past. Resistance can also be below the physical level of violence. Frank hoffmans paper on hybrid wars is a masterpiece of enlightened thinking on conflict in our time. Abstract the history of war is divided into five distinct eras starting from the mid 1640s. Pdf are africas wars part of a fourth generation of warfare. Jul 28, 2016 the man who came up with the concept of 4gw, william s.
Fifth generation warfare a growing concept security debrief. How 4th generation warfare helps to explain the rise of. In simple terms, 4gw is a conflict characterized by a blurring of the lines between war and politics, combatants and civilians. Discussing fifth generation warfare 5gw makes me think of this quote from the bible. Now fourth, which is sometimes referred to as fifth generation warfare is the use of the economy to either bring down a country or to persuade a country to change its behavior based on economic pressures. The fallacies of fourth and fifth generation warfare by derek k. Many technical and some political aspects of these fourthgeneration nuclear. The genesis of an ideabased fourth genera tion may be visible in terrorism. The characteristics of fifth generation warfare would be the sudden and inexplicable eruption of violence against the visible symbols of state strength such as law enforcing agencies.
However, there are criticisms about their study of the fourth generation as it does not cover the present situation junio, 2009 and lacks scientific and historical roots with. Again, all these elements are present in third generation warfare. Hammes strategic forum f ourth generation warfare, which is now playing out in iraq and afghanistan, is a modern form of insurgency. Pdf this article looks at the nature of fourth generation warfare 4gw, and how theories such as the clash of. Fourthgeneration warfare as presented by lind et al. Dec, 2014 fourth generation warfare 4gw is a concept defined by william s. Wilson at this writing, the american military response to 11 september has been confined to the war in afghanistan.
Fourth generation war 4gw emerged in the late 1980s, but has become popular due to recent twists in the war in iraq and terrorist attacks worldwide. In terms of generational modern warfare, the fourth generation signifies the nation states loss of their nearmonopoly on combat forces, returning to modes of conflict common in premodern times. While fourth generation agents share similar characteristics with other nerve agents, fourth. Another characteristic of fourthgeneration warfare is that unlike in third generation warfare, the vnsas. Two schools of thought have formed one touting 4gw as the latest in modern warfare, the other regarding 4gw as an adaption of classical lowintensity warfare methods to modern communications and propaganda methods. Defining fifth generation warfare military embedded systems. Fourthgeneration warfare is characterized by a blurring of the lines between war and politics, combatants and civilians. Changing characteristics of warfare and the future of. Its practitioners seek to convince enemy political leaders that their strategic goals are either unachievable or too costly for the. It should be required reading for all students and practitioners of modern warfare.
Generally fought by agrarian and pastoral societies, and runs f. Fifth generation warfare a growing concept security. Jan 18, 2019 this guide was developed as part of ongoing preparedness for all hazards and is intended to inform decisions, protect emergency responders, and support response operations if an incident ever occurs involving a fourth generation agent fga, also known as aseries or novichok nerve agents, such as the one used in the united kingdom in 2018. Fifth generation air warfare may be conceived as comprising four parts. In terms of generational modern warfare, the fourth generation signifies the nation states loss of their nearmonopoly on. A 4gw adversary might use the tactics of an insurgent, terrorist, or guerrilla in order to wage war against a nations infrastructure. The purpose of this book is to provide a broad outline for how a presentday western military might be reorganized to gift a. The term fourth generation warfare 4gw is not internationally defined. For this reason, it receives numerous requests for gaming support from throughout the u. Other cognitive factor anomalies exist, moving into the fourth generation of warfare 40, where enemy strategy is driven by unfair or irrational actions. Fifth generation air warfare thinking the fifth generation air warfare concept is a powerful one but to be best applied needs to be understood. Characteristics such as decentralization and initiative carry over from the third to the fourth generation, but in other respects the fourth generation marks the most radical change since the peace of westphalia. Lind, to describe warfare s return to a decentralized form. A critique of 4gw is both fortuitous and important.
The tactics and characteristics of 4gw can be described with three levels. Someelementsin terroram appearto reflect the previously qoted canyovers from third generation warfare. Their unifying concept is that 21st century warfare in the post911 world requires a. Fourthgeneration warfare 4gw is conflict characterized by a blurring of the lines between war and politics, combatants and civilians the term was first used in 1980 by a team of united states analysts, including paleoconservative william s. Pdf this paper examines the relevance of the ideas encompassed by fourth generation warfare 4gw in the context of warfare in africa. Mar 12, 2020 the first three generations of warfare are generally described as. The first three generations of warfare are generally described as.
The fallacies of fourth and fifth generation warfare. Characteristics such as decentralization and initiative carry over from the third to the fourth generation, but in other respects the fourth generation marks the most radical change since the peace of westphalia in 1648. An interesting quick read lind has some reasonableseeming points to make about fighting counterinsurgency wars in a modern environment. Fourth generation adversaries will be adept at manipulating the media to alter domestic and world opiniontelevision news may become a more powerful operational weapon than armored divisions some terrorists already know how to play this game. With fourth generation warfare, there may even be no single organisation and that smaller groups organize into impromptu alliances to target a bigger threat that being the state armed forces or another faction. Fourth generation warfare takes place on all fronts. Understanding fourth generation warfare 89 understanding fourthgeneration warfare and its relevance to pakistan khurshid khan and afifa kiran. In recent years, military thinkers have been focused on fourthgeneration warfare that is, conflicts over ideas, waged by what author john robb calls adhoc warriors. Lind, writes in his book, 4 th generation warfare handbook, that mindset of a 4gw warrior is that of a light infantryman.
Jan 15, 2004 characteristics such as decentralization and initiative carry over from the third to the fourth generation, but in other respects the fourth generation marks the most radical change since the peace of westphalia in 1648. Third generation warfare emerged at the end of wwi and continued into wwii and beyond. This thesis refers to the new way of war as fourth generation war 4gw and this analysis is restricted to the army component of the defense forces. The third generation was tanks, artilleries, and air force. Military response to fourth generation warfare in afghanistan.
A tool of hybrid warfare used by antipakistan forces. Fifth generation warfare and the challenges for pakistan. Many technical and some political aspects of these fourth generation nuclear. Fourth generation warfare 4gw, though as old as the history of war itself, has acquired a new character with. Fourth generation agents, also known as novichoks or aseries nerve agents, belong to a category of chemical warfare agents that are unique organophosphorus compounds. Despite reinventing itself several times, the theory has several fundamental flaws that need to be exposed before they can cause harm to u. The framework is the four generations of modern war. In terms of generational modern warfare, the fourth generation signifies the nation states. Nonstate entities fighting fourth generation warfare in mexico philip treglia major, u. Fought with firearms but not repeating arms or self. Another characteristic of fourthgeneration warfare is that unlike in third generation warfare, the vnsas forces are decentralized.
In fourth generation war, the state loses its monopoly on war. Barnett in evaluating current warfighting trends and reconciliatory attempts to understand said trends, it appears the conceptual model of fourthgeneration warfare 4gw and, by extension, fifthgeneration warfare 5gw has achieved a level of dominant preeminence to. Fourthgeneration warfare 4gw is conflict characterized by a blurring of the lines between war. These are all important ideas that do not exist individually but rather function together as an integrated interdependent system of systems where the whole is greater than the parts. Fourth generation warfare 4gw is combat characterized by a blurring of the lines between war and politics, soldier and civilian, peace and conflict, battlefield and safety. The civil war third generation warfare with the beginnings of some detachment from the actual battle field. Understanding fourth ipri journal generation warfare 89. The authors of the paper went on to speculate on the nature of fourth generation warfare which, too, would be driven partially by technology and partially by ideas. Case studies rhodesia, punjab, kosovo, france show the. Hybrid warfare is the 5th generation nonconventional warfare.
This guide was developed as part of ongoing preparedness for all hazards and is intended to inform decisions, protect emergency responders, and support response operations if an incident ever occurs involving a fourth generation agent fga, also known as aseries or novichok nerve agents, such as the one used in the united kingdom in 2018. In the late 1980s, fourth generation warfare 4gw theorists began to recognize a shift in warfare which they assumed was both in the character and nature of war. Armies at present are geared to fight the earlier generation of attrition and maneuver wars. Fourthgeneration warfare pentagon mavericks have been trying for decades to reorient military strategy toward a new kind of threatthe kind were suddenly facing in the war on terrorism.
Barnett in evaluating current warfighting trends and reconciliatory attempts to understand said trends, it appears the conceptual model of fourth generation warfare 4gw and, by extension, fifth generation warfare 5gw has achieved a level of dominant preeminence to. Hammes, fourth generation warfare evolves, fifth emerges, p. Lind, colonel keith nightengale usa, captain john f. Are africas wars part of a fourth generation of warfare. The 4gw actor can be driven by ideas, religion, or the defense of the purity of its race. Diplomats, soldiers, law enforcement officers, intelligence operatives, cyber warriors and development specialists are being aided by sociologists, psychologists, and policy academicians. It may be too early to look at lessons learned, but it is not too early for an assessment of. A new and very interesting concept is growing among a community of dedicated national security professionals. Modern warfare evolves into a fourth generation by thomas x.
62 355 959 975 1287 310 1458 491 1127 1249 826 750 1413 1395 447 534 526 1413 879 607 201 1187 434 1213 777 736 1169 91 640 214 971 330 1392 1243 723 1097 1434 1390 538 254 185 1319 433 1360 425 111 730 407